Is Too Much Cinnamon Bad for You?

Is Too Much Cinnamon Bad for You? at
source: mhiguera

My pregnancies are typically marked more by food aversions than food cravings (with the exception of the Eggo waffles incident), but one thing I have been consistently craving this pregnancy is cinnamon. Oatmeal with fresh apples or nectarines and tons of cinnamon? Yes please. Sweet potatoes with ghee and a generous coating of cinnamon. Mm hmm. Apple slices sprinkled with cinnamon? YES!

However, in the midst of all of my cinnamon-y cravings, I vaguely remembered reading a post somewhere about too much cinnamon being a bad thing.

At the time, I’m pretty sure I wrote it off as “everything is bad for you according to somebody”, but seeing as how there is a little person growing inside of me now, I figured maybe it was worth looking into just a little bit more.

And sadly, it’s true. Too much cinnamon can be a very bad thing. This is a fact agreed to by conventional sources as well as natural sources, which is usually a pretty good sign that it’s something worth paying attention to.

The good news? Not all cinnamon is bad; just the stuff we buy in the grocery store. The bad news? The other stuff is — of course — more expensive.

Cassia Cinnamon Versus True Cinnamon

Although this makes me shake my head a little bit, the cinnamon you buy in the store is not actually cinnamon. It comes from cassia bark (which is related to cinnamon but not actually cinnamon).

Because cassia bark is more easily harvested, it’s less expensive and more readily available. Honestly, it’s the distinct flavor of this variety that I love.

The problem? All cinnamon contains a compound known as coumarin. Actually, a lot of food does, so that in itself is not a problem. The problem is that cassia cinnamon has especially high levels of coumarin, which can be harmful to your liver or kidneys and thin your blood in relatively small doses — not a great combination of factors. Because of this, there are official recommendations in some European countries to avoid cassia cinnamon altogether.

On the other hand, true cinnamon is known as Sri Lankan or Ceylon cinnamon (because that’s where it’s grown), and it contains almost negligible amounts of coumarin. You can easily buy it online from a spice retailer such as Penzeys or even from Amazon (which is where I got mine), and I would imagine that any health food stores that sell spices or herbs might have it as well! There isn’t an easy way to tell the powders apart (although price may be a good indicator), but ceylon cinnamon sticks are thinner with many layers, and they can easily be ground at home, whereas cassia cinnamon sticks are thicker and extremely hard.

Honestly, ceylon cinnamon has a different flavor than “conventional” cinnamon. It’s not a bad flavor…just different. I’ve read descriptions of it including subtle, sweet and delicate while calling the flavor of cassia cinnamon harsh, although I still honestly prefer the cassia flavor.

That said, at this point I’m replacing my daily cinnamon intake — on oatmeal and french toast and sweet potatoes, for example — with the more expensive ceylon cinnamon and reserving the conventional “cheap” stuff for baked goods and other recipes where I really want that traditional cinnamon flavor and won’t be consuming large amounts of it.

If your family only uses cinnamon sparingly in baking, I’m honestly not sure this is worth over-thinking or worrying about. However, if you use it generously and often like we do, it may be worth the switch!

How much cinnamon do you use? Do you buy ceylon cinnamon?

This Post Has One Comment

  1. One thing we should mention is that eating cinnamon during pregnancy can induce uterine contractions resulting in premature birth. Yes Ceylon Cinnamon tastes milder tasting, but again, the fresher it is, the more aromatic and stronger it tastes and smells. It all depends how it was handled, whether it was sitting exposed to sunlight in a glass bottle or packed in an air tight, oxygen and moisture proof alufoil bag or container.

    For a given recipe you actually have to double the amount of Ceylon Cinnamon, but even doubling will not come close to the hepatoxity levels of Cassia Cinnamon. Since many people are using cinnamon on a daily basis for better health, it is better to switch Ceylon Cinnamon. Yes occasionally you can use Cassia Cinnamon.

    Of course the Western way of using cinnamon is in sweet recipes. The Asians primarily use it in none sweet recipes like stews, curries and soups. That is the healthier way to use cinnamon. And that’s where Ceylon cinnamon comes into it’s own, creating complex sophisticated flavors that are out of this World.

    But because Ceylon cinnamon is fractionally sweeter with hints of citrus and cloves we think it works even better with baked goods, cost not with standing. There is no overt hint of cinnamon in the taste but the aroma is far more fragrant and exotic than Cassia Cinnamon and the taste is just extraordinary. Try it in a butter cake or Cinnamon French toast, but mix it in the toast mixture and then fry it.

Comments are closed.

Close Menu